Strong track record in HOA disputes where he wins consistently and knows Florida property law deeply. Serious concerns arise in eviction and tenant matters: one client paid $4000 upfront then received minimal representation, with McGrath charging for calls to end the relationship itself. High fees and substantial retainers are standard but outcomes vary sharply by case type.
Based on limited recent reviews, so treat this as low-confidence.
Recent shift: The most recent negative review (1 star, 1 year ago) echoes complaints from earlier negative reviews (4+ years ago) about upfront charges and slow progress, suggesting a persistent pattern rather than recent deterioration.
Most clients feel heard and supported through their bankruptcy and legal challenges. Jeff Badgley and his core team (Cynthia, Giselle) deliver clear guidance and calm people through stressful filings, but appointment reliability and staff communication have been inconsistent for some. A few clients reported feeling dismissed or dropped when cases seemed complex or unprofitable.
Strong clients credit Perez Conrique Law with quick callbacks, clear explanations, and successful outcomes, particularly in foreclosure defense and debt collection matters. However, some past clients report unresponsiveness to consultation requests, poor case strategy, and high costs without matching results. The firm also faces criticism for sending unsolicited foreclosure warning letters to prospects with current accounts.
Most reviews praise Joe Mancuso for winning cases, fair pricing, and strong communication. Several clients credit him with beating lawsuits and resolving bankruptcy and foreclosure matters within months. However, a minority report harsh treatment from front desk and paralegal staff during intake, and some describe years-long inaction on cases and disputes over refunds that required regulatory involvement to resolve. The firm lists services across debt collection defense, consumer protection, bankruptcy, and foreclosure. Payment plans are available. Clients who follow instructions and provide documents on time report smoother experiences, while those facing complex cases or payment disputes describe frustration with responsiveness and account handling.
Last updated 2026-08-27